All American Butter- Butter My Cup Peanut Butter

  • Sale
  • Regular price $14.99
Shipping calculated at checkout.


If you love the taste of Reeses chocolate peanut butter cups, you’re going to love the Butter My Cup Peanut Butter! Enjoy our signature all natural peanut butter with chopped Reese's cups, mini Reese’s chips, and all the delicious flavors you’d find in your favorite candy. The best part is, it’s actually good for you! Our peanut butter has:

  • 9 grams of protein per serving 
  • Low sugar 
  • Low carb
  • Gluten free 

All of our peanut butters are handmade in small batches right here in our very own kitchens. You won’t be able to put this container down! 

All orders are made fresh after your order is placed. It will take a couple of days for us to handcraft your butter and then 2-3 days for shipping. It’s worth the wait, we promise! 

Please be aware that as it gets warmer outside, during the shipping process any orders with chocolate products or other toppings may melt. Your package may also get flipped during shipping and may not arrive looking like the picture.